Scialo Bros. Bakery squeaked by The Original Italian Bakery by a 52%-48% difference. Because ranking these choices is hard, we started by placing the names into an online randomizer to determine ...

While two of the matchups had clear winners, two came down to Friday's voting deadline with votes cast right up to the end, as Deluise Bakery topped Vesta Bakery by a 54%-46% margin and in an even ...