1979 - Tom Cousineau: The No. 1 overall choice never played a down for the Bills. He refused to sign a contract, went to the CFL for a few years and after the Bills traded his rights to Cleveland he signed with the Browns but never did much.

As we all know, not every selection works as planned. That's the case with these 32 players identified by SI.com's Matt Verderame. Looking back throughout the league's history, he identifies the biggest draft bust of all-time for every team. For the Bills, it winds up being a No. 1 overall pick who never suited up for them.

It of course isn’t QB or bust for the Bills in 2025 — but is there a consensus about what Buffalo should do in this year’s draft?